A tough watch on the South Coast as Newcastle defended well but never looked like scoring in a bore draw away to Bournemouth.
Here are our marks out of 10 from yesterday’s game, along with our comments on each player involved:
Starting 11
Pope (7) – A big save in each half preserved yet another clean sheet. Still looks lost coming out of his area or with the ball at his feet but he’s paid to keep the ball out and he’s doing a fine job!
Livramento (7) – Looks more at home on the right and handled his defensive responsibilities well. Made one notable block when he threw himself in front of the ball.
Thiaw (7.5) – Looks the part already. Calm and composed in possession and strong in defence. Propensity for playing it back to Pope which caused heart rates to increase though! Will be hard to dislodge if he keep it up. Hooked due to “fatigue” but realistically he was taken off to avoid a second yellow, which he was lucky to avoid!
Botman (8) – Quality throughout. Took his opportunity with both hands and didn’t put a foot wrong. When he’s on form he makes defending look easy. Dominant, read the play well and played a few nice line-breaking passes out from the back.
Burn (7) – The least impressive of the back three which is not a criticism as they all played well. Solid and dealt with Semenyo well, but a few sloppy giveaways and feels like he should be utilised better off set pieces. Have our set pieces improved with our new coach?
Hall (6.5) – Looked very rusty early on but gradually grew into the game. Will be better for the run and will have more impactful performances
Miley (5.5) – Never quite got a foothold in midfield unfortunately. Seems to be lacking confidence at times. Would love to see him play more freely as the potential is clearly there
Tonali (7) – Carried the heavy lifting in midfield all by himself. Ran his socks off and produced some timely progressive carries to drag the team up the pitch. Undroppable
Willock (4) – A shadow of his former self and was completely ineffective. Was outmuscled on more than one occasion and his usual strong ball carrying has deserted him. Might not start again for a while.
Murphy (6) – Started brightly but then fizzled out as we offered very little in attack. Had a rare shot on target which was too close to Petrovic, opting to go for the near post when the play was surely striking into the far corner. Nowhere near his best but he wasn’t alone.
Woltemade (6) – Showed some neat touches and tried to link the play, but also lost most of his aerial duels and gave up possession on several occasions. We haven’t quite cracked the code on how to best utilise him and could’ve won a penalty if he didn’t go down so theatrically.
Subs
Elanga (5.5) – Made some decent runs but the service in to him was poor which summed up out attacking performance.
Barnes (5.5) – Much like Elanga, didn’t really have an opportunity to show what he could offer in attack. Will likely get some minutes against Bradford to hopefully get his confidence in front of goal back
Osula (NR) – Came on for the last five minutes as Woltemade tired.
Lascelles (NR) – See above. But good to see him make his first Premier League appearance since 2023/24 after a tough spell with injuries.
Thought milley did well, Willock should have been sold 2 seasons ago, he’s not a premier league player for me and apart from his loan spell has never looked like one,,
Tonali MOTM, Botman did very well, hope Woltermeade settles soon, he doesn’t look a force yet, will take him time to get used to the Pace, intensity and physicality of the premier league, he is not a normal looking striker, more like a link up player another striker will play off.
At the moment I can’t see where the goals will come from.
MorpethMag(Quote)
Willock’s a busted flush unfortunately and needs to be moved on asap.
Absolutely glorious(Quote)
The rating for Hall is way off..
Joppadoni(Quote)
We build these players up in our minds way beyond what they deserve.
Miley hasn’t had much match time, and a few more hours on the pitch will see him back to where he was.
Willock however is an example of fans overestimating ability.
He had a run where he scored 7 goals in 7 matches, then we bought him.|
Since then there was a pass with the outside of his right boot against Spurs, and that’s about it.
JFA127(Quote)
Wilock, Murphy and pope they are in the team because they are British simple as that …if we want to achieve champions league position every year and compete for trophies we need top recruitment..problem is eddie howe literally doesn’t have a clue about European talent..his nephew is apparently our sporting director
Henock ethiopia(Quote)
I don’t understand our strategy…our scouts have done well in the last 3 years u can see it at under 18 games ..our under 21 is ****…we pay more because a player is British not talent..I truly gave up when Paul mitchell left because he was right…its a team with no clear ideology….no plans what so ever
Henock ethiopia(Quote)
On the plus I endured mike caslys era…so i really can’t complain..but understanding we will never be man city should sink in to us fans …
Henock ethiopia(Quote)