NUFC Blog
Session loading

Alan Shearer questions Newcastle’s new transfer strategy

by Olly Hawkins ·
Alan Shearer questions Newcastle’s new transfer strategy

Alan Shearer has questioned Newcastle’s new recruitment strategy, admitting we have yet to see the benefits of a summer window that brought significant investment but very little immediate impact from several of our new arrivals.

Speaking to Betfair ahead of tonight's clash with Arsenal, the Newcastle legend believes we need to find a better balance between young prospects and experienced players.

Shearer unsure on summer transfer strategy

Shearer was particularly critical of the lack of impact from our younger summer signings, while also highlighting the importance of having experienced players available.

“We haven’t seen the benefits of Newcastle’s transfer strategy yet and if it was that easy, everyone would do it.

“For me, you have to find the balance between young players and experienced players. They’ve got Joelinton in there but he gets injured quite a bit and they have struggled with one or two injuries.

“But at the minute, we haven’t seen anywhere near enough of the transfers that they made in the summer….whether that’s Bazoumana Toure, Aladji Bamba, Matias Fernandez-Pardo or Sean Steur. There was a lot spent but we’ve not seen that work as of yet.”

It is a fair criticism of a summer window in which we, under Ross Wilson's guidance, made a conscious decision to lower the average age of the squad and invest heavily in players with potential.

However, with several of those signings struggling to get regular minutes, particularly Toure and Bamba, and results proving inconsistent, questions are naturally being asked about whether that strategy has left us short of the experience needed to compete immediately.

Newcastle need to find the right balance

There is no doubt that recruiting young talent can bring long-term benefits, but we cannot afford to sacrifice too much experience in the process.

The likes of Bazoumana Touré, Aladji Bamba, Matias Fernandez-Pardo and Sean Steur may yet prove to be excellent signings, but we need to see more from them on the pitch.

Injuries have not helped, while the departures of experienced figures like Bruno, Trippier and Lascelles have also left a leadership gap within the squad.

Shearer is not necessarily questioning the potential of those brought in, but his point is clear; potential alone is not enough. We need players capable of making an immediate difference alongside those who can develop over time.

That balance will be particularly important when the January transfer window opens, with Matthias Jaissle already keen to add more goals and experience to his squad.

Topics
Latest NUFC News